27 October 2026  ·  Policy

More S5 appeals: passing the gateway, and losing the balance

Eleven more appeal decisions on housing outside settlements, issued from 17 September to 23 October 2026, add five readings of policy S5 to those in the first note. None refers to the minister's letter.

On 22 October 2026 an inspector found a site not "physically well-related" to a village because its main access would be unsafe. That decision, at Charlton Horethorne in Somerset, is one of eleven on housing outside settlements, issued from 17 September to 23 October 2026, that the first note on S5 did not cover.

They were found through reported cases and the Planning Inspectorate's appeals service. This is not a census, and each decision is one inspector's reading. Five of the eleven were appeals for permission in principle, which settles only location, land use and the amount of development. In all eleven the authority could not show, or had not shown, a five-year housing land supply.

Six were allowed, five dismissed. Charlton Horethorne and Sutton Benger failed the gateway, the S5(1) test that a scheme fits a listed category. Hawthorn and Haslemere passed it and lost the balance, the test that follows.

The eleven

AppealPlace and authorityHomesDecided, 2026Gateway resultOutcome
6006581Haslemere, Waverley1417 SeptemberPassed, S5(1)(h)Dismissed, balance lost
6008238Buntingford, East HertfordshireUp to 600, plus up to 60 for older people24 SeptemberPassed, S5(1)(j)Allowed
6008576Wilmslow, Cheshire East25 OctoberGreen Belt, GB7(1)(g) metAllowed
6005671Wivelsfield Green, LewesUp to 1506 OctoberAccords with S5, no relationship findingAllowed
6010963Westerleigh, South Gloucestershire913 OctoberGreen Belt, GB7(1)(g)(iii) failedDismissed
6014063Nash, Buckinghamshire1 to 221 OctoberPassed, S5(1)(j)Allowed
6007418Hawthorn, County Durham8122 OctoberPassed, S5(1)(j)Dismissed, balance lost
6003449Charlton Horethorne, Somerset3122 OctoberFailed, S5(1)(j)Dismissed
6005101Great Abington, South CambridgeshireUp to 4023 OctoberPassed, S5(1)(j)Allowed
6009187Sutton Benger, WiltshireUp to 923 OctoberFailed, S5(1)(j)Dismissed
6008517Mevagissey, Cornwall823 OctoberPassed, S5(1)(j)Allowed

The first eight

AppealPlace and authorityWell relatedOutcome
6009593Washington, HorshamNoAllowed under S5(1)(d) and (e)
6005108Drayton, Vale of White HorseYesAllowed
6005809Kingston Bagpuize, Vale of White HorseYesAllowed
6006900Findon, South Downs National ParkNoDismissed
6008253Aston Clinton, BuckinghamshireNoAllowed under S5(4)
6009363Brigsley, North East LincolnshireYesDismissed, particularly on L3
6009048Needingworth, HuntingdonshireYesAllowed
6008560Tattenhall, Cheshire West and ChesterNoDismissed

Gateway passed, balance lost

At Haslemere the site was physically well-related "in proximity and spatial connectivity terms" despite landscape harm (paragraph 79). At Hawthorn the site was "physically well-related" because it abutted built form and had accessible walking and cycling routes (paragraph 51). Under a local policy whose test covers heritage and landscape effects and locational sustainability, the same decision found it "would not be well-related to Hawthorn" (paragraph 49). The balance went against 81 homes: harm to a conservation area and to an Area of Higher Landscape Value, and a location without "a genuine choice of modes of transport", each carried substantial weight (paragraph 52).

In none of the nine decisions outside the Green Belt did harm to character or setting make the housing fail the gateway. Where inspectors found that harm, they weighed it in the balance. That is the opposite of Aston Clinton in the first note, which found its site not well related because of harm to character and setting, and leaves the question that note raised still open.

Five new readings

Access safety counted at the gateway. At Charlton Horethorne the main access was "unacceptable in highways safety terms", so the development "would not be physically well-related to the existing settlement" (paragraph 51). The lane was narrow with no footway, and the measures offered, including passing places and a "virtual path", "would fail to address this harm satisfactorily" (paragraphs 26, 34 and 38). At Buntingford, bridges and a toucan crossing over the A10, found acceptable, counted towards a well-related finding (paragraphs 21 and 56). For applicants, the route from site to settlement is gateway evidence. An authority can argue highway concerns at the gateway too.

A recent permission set the edge. At Sutton Benger, development already permitted outside the settlement boundary had, in the inspector's words, "formed a well-defined edge to development". The site "sits beyond this and would result in an awkwardly located finger of development which would protrude into the open countryside" (paragraph 18). An applicant beyond the latest consent may have to answer on shape as well as distance. An authority can use recent consents to show the edge.

Unmet need was split, as a fallback. At Great Abington the inspector concluded that "the Council has not demonstrated a five-year housing land supply" (paragraph 33). Paragraph 125 adds that "even if I were to accept the Council's latest 5YHLS position of 7.83 years", the agreed unmet need for affordable and self-build homes would still meet S5(1)(j), but "the market housing element of the proposal would not find support". S5(4) would be engaged, and the benefits "would substantially outweigh the adverse effects" (paragraph 127). If followed, an authority's five-year supply would not close S5(1)(j) for the affordable and self-build share of a scheme, and an applicant would need evidence on each kind of need.

National Landscape harm was graded. At Mevagissey, where the whole village is inside the Cornwall National Landscape, the inspector found "only moderate harm", localised, and granted permission in principle for eight homes (paragraphs 7, 22 and 25). At Haslemere, where about 70% of the site is in the Surrey Hills National Landscape, the harm was "considerable" and its "permanence and irreversibility" carried weight that "would substantially outweigh the substantial benefits" of 14 homes (paragraphs 10, 31 and 90). Both inspectors gave substantial weight to conserving natural beauty and differed on the grade of harm. The Mevagissey permission in principle left design to a later stage (paragraph 17). For both sides, the grade of harm found on the site evidence tracked the outcome: considerable at Haslemere, only moderate at Mevagissey. Mevagissey also notes that earlier appeals on the same site found similar harm but failed under a different framework, as full applications, and when the council had a five-year supply (paragraph 26).

S5 is set aside in the Green Belt. Policy S5(5) takes the Green Belt and Local Green Space out of S5, as Westerleigh says: "Policy S5 does not apply given the site's location in the Green Belt" (paragraph 37). Wilmslow applied GB7, then the favourable balance that S5(5) keeps for development that is not inappropriate (paragraphs 17 and 18). Both used GB7(1)(g): grey belt land, an evidenced unmet need, a site "in a sustainable location, with particular reference to policy TR3", and, for major housing, the Golden Rules. Westerleigh failed the third limb on sustainable travel and highway safety, and there was no compelling evidence of very special circumstances (paragraphs 13 to 22). An applicant on grey belt answers for the site's contribution to Green Belt purposes and its travel evidence. Failing any one limb takes a scheme out of GB7(1)(g).

The minister's letter

No decision refers to it. The letter, dated 6 October 2026 and published on 7 October, describes "a universal tilt in favour of granting permission". Searches of the eleven decisions for "Minister", "Pennycook", "universal tilt" and "letter" found nothing, though seven came after its publication. A decision's silence does not show whether the inspector had read the letter.

Sources

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, National Planning Policy Framework, August 2026, policies S5 and GB7.
  2. Matthew Pennycook MP, letter to the chief executive of the Planning Inspectorate, 6 October 2026.
  3. Appeal decisions 6006581 (Haslemere, 17 September 2026), 6008238 (Buntingford, 24 September), 6008576 (Wilmslow, 5 October), 6005671 (Wivelsfield Green, 6 October), 6010963 (Westerleigh, 13 October), 6014063 (Nash, 21 October), 6007418 (Hawthorn, 22 October), 6003449 (Charlton Horethorne, 22 October), 6005101 (Great Abington, 23 October), 6009187 (Sutton Benger, 23 October) and 6008517 (Mevagissey, 23 October), via the Planning Inspectorate's appeals service.
  4. The eight decisions in the first note: 6009593, 6005108, 6005809, 6006900, 6008253, 6009363, 6009048 and 6008560.

Does this affect a site you are working on?

Tell us the question. No charge for the first conversation, and no obligation after it.